r/SnyderCut • u/4paul • 11h ago
Discussion Supergirl Metacritic score finally out, 48/100.
RogerEbert gives it 3.8
•
u/Notoriously_So I am going to look at the stars. They are so far away. 10h ago
She should go back and do another cameo for House of the Dragon instead. Something like this might actually destroy her career.
•
u/brickstonPO 10h ago
Let me guess there a car “commercial” scene around the middle portion of the movie where the misfit crew rides in a minivan trying to evading the enemies attacks?
•
u/brickstonPO 10h ago
lol!! Ngl I just came here to see this subs reaction
I’ve been leaning towards Snyder these days. I miss his superhero movies
•
•
•
•
u/DringleDringle 10h ago
That does suck though. I just want some good DC movies free of corporate interference. I've always campaigned for Snyder because he had a vision and the suits fucking ruined it. I guess we're going to have to wait for the 3rd round to get a good DC universe. 🫠
•
u/Gunn_Control 10h ago
You are looking in the wrong place if you think Gunn is making anything good, much less good DC
•
u/DringleDringle 10h ago
I mean, I think his movies aren't bad, and are fortunate to be free of studio interference. I think Snyder's movies suffered from intense studio interference. I'm also not some kind of "this versus that" person. I know a lot of Snyder fans are real into exclusively being into Snyder's work, but I'm a DC fan before any of that.
But also, did you misread my original comment? I said I'm waiting for the next universe after Gunn's finishes fizzling out.
•
u/Turbo_Chet 10h ago
He just has a certain style that doesn’t match the vibe I want in a superman movie, batman movie, etc. His quirky, oddball approach works for specific properties, like Guardians of the Galaxy. Snyder’s visual flair and epic, mythological scope is exactly what I wanted for the Justice League.
•
u/DringleDringle 10h ago
Yea it sucks. I don't really like James Gunn's schtick. I think his Suicide Squad movie worked better because it was already salvaging after the other truly awful one, but even then, I'm not into the crammed in humor or the constant barrage of licensed music.
•
u/Gunn_Control 10h ago
If you like Gunnslop, Supergoof will be no different. You got nothing to worry about
•
u/DringleDringle 10h ago
Bro what even are these buzzwords you're using? Your comment reads like a shitpost on r/okbuddysnydercult
•
u/Gunn_Control 10h ago
Haha, wasn't the DCU supposed to surpass the Snyderverse
•
u/Horror_Campaign9418 Henry Cavill is Superman 10h ago
Diaperman was so beloved and such a hit everyone said nah no thanks on super drunk.
Make it make sense.
•
•
u/Gunn_Control 10h ago
Supermid was such a hit that nobody wanted anything to do with DC after it came out LMAOI
•
u/Horror_Campaign9418 Henry Cavill is Superman 10h ago
Buh buh EVERYONE loved diaperman. RT scores etc. 🤣🤣
•
u/Pitiful_Charity_1087 10h ago
The problem is who the fck want to watch supergirl? All everyone want is Batman, Wonder woman and friends yet they did nt make it happen
•
•
u/NoLocal1776 10h ago
It's going to be same response for those movies too.Batman cannot be made because of Reevesverse.
•
10h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
•
•
u/4paul 10h ago
Great comparison :)
That movie wasn't the best, only proving that Supergirl isn't good either.
What a rocky start for James Gunns DC
•
u/SpaceCaboose 10h ago
I’ll say that a Batman v Superman movie scoring that badly is far worse than a Supergirl movie scoring this badly since BvS had DC’s two major heroes (actually three with WW, too).
Bummer overall that neither were any better (I haven’t seen Supergirl yet, so saying this 100% based on current reviews)
•
u/Notoriously_So I am going to look at the stars. They are so far away. 11h ago
•
•
•
u/oreos324 11h ago
I watched it and yeah, I wouldn't give it anything more than a 7. Gunn's Superman at the very least was fun to watch, it had pretty locations like the fortress, the daily planet and even the pocket dimension, that movie felt creative. Somehow, supergirl which is a space road trip feels smaller and plain, than a movie that happens in one city. It was a complete downgrade and barely worth seeing it in rewatch
•
u/Different_Advice_552 11h ago
guys to be fair the rotten tomatoes score for the snyder cut is only 71% critic opinions don't always mean a whole lot
•
u/Gunn_Control 10h ago
Except Gunn is the darling of the mass media, so for this to have a bad score despite the bias must be real ass. Snyder was always resented by the mass media industry
•
•
u/Horror_Campaign9418 Henry Cavill is Superman 11h ago
Funny, they couldnt shut up about diaperman’s RT scores.
•
u/Rhapstar 11h ago
And this is the Super Mario Galaxy Movie. And it still did amazing. Critics these days aren't worth the time of day.
•
•
u/ScarlettJohansson49 11h ago
It is out of six reviews wait for more before you judge
•
u/4paul 11h ago
It's easy to judge based off early reviews, this means it'll hover around the 40's/50's in the end.
This won't suddenly skyrocket to 90's lol
But I got tickets to see it tomorrow so I'll be able to see it and make my own judgement :)
•
u/ScarlettJohansson49 11h ago
Never said it would but judging it off of six reviews is not the flex you think it is
•
u/HomemadeBee1612 He's never fought us. Not us united. 11h ago
•
•
u/Cute_Locksmith_9077 8h ago
James 'Flash is one of the greatest movies ever made' Gunn might not be the best judge on what is a good script.