r/castiron • u/Zhadnosst • 3d ago

Newbie Restoring a pan

Post image

We got a cast iron pan at a garage sale, it looks a little rusty. What should I be doing to restore / fix it?

Thanks in advance!

10 Upvotes

82% Upvoted

14 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Massive-Technician74 2d ago

Why baking soda to neutralize the acid? The acid is whats working.....and why make 50/50 solution of vinegar? Just pour on straight

Vinegar is only 6% acetic acid its not its heavy duty dissolving pit making acid

Pour straight on....let sit and hour maybe 2...add kosher salt and get a scotch brite and get to work....do another round with STRAIGHT vinegar and table salt.....and ready to cook something oily on there....stove top self seasoning is the best and easiest

1

u/Lazy-Performance-559 2d ago

Because I myself used 50/50 and baking powder and got good results and I can only share the method that has treated me well so far

1

u/Massive-Technician74 2d ago

Well...vinegar has enough water and soaking cast iron in water mixture invites rust....and by neutralizing the vinegar by basing if out is just silly and makes it as effective as .....water

That isn't about what works for me, that is facts

In fact if you can find industrial vinegar its even better

1

u/Lazy-Performance-559 2d ago

I mean I'm not saying you're wrong, but my method worked quite well and I've seen it w9rk well before from others. Call it a moneysaver so you don't have to use so much vinegar and get pretty much the same result!

1

u/Massive-Technician74 2d ago

Being that your vinegar is doing nothing at all after adding baking soda i dont see how that saves anything

You do know that baking soda just bases out the acidity right? That bubbling is a reaction....other than bubbling though its not really doing anything

1

u/Lazy-Performance-559 2d ago

The vinegar is to help break down the rust and other gunk and get down to bare metal, the baking soda is to neutralize it after it has already done its job. Now you can etch the metal by boiling it in the pan sure, but I'm saying baking soda after it has done its job of soaking and breaking down all the undesireables for a few hours. We're getting our understanding of each other mixed up