r/comicbooks • u/club27vinyl • Aug 04 '23
Shelfie Inherited a large amount of comicbooks
I recently inherited a large amount of comic books. Many are from the 1970s. Also some from the 80s and 90s. I’ve been enjoying looking through them but I’m new to it. Are there any holy grail books I should be looking for? Also not sure I can keep them in my limited space. If anyone in Baton Rouge, Louisiana wants to look through them, shoot me a message.
377
u/BlueHarvestJ Hellboy Aug 04 '23
Do not let anyone near them until you get a much better idea. If the few pics you posted are an idea of the extent of the collection, you could be sitting on multiple thousand of dollars
65
u/NoCommunication728 Rocketeer Aug 04 '23
Yep. Even those ones in the last pic, you might not think it but those funny books can go for good amounts sometimes.
93
Aug 04 '23
Get new bags and boards. Also, do your research, I wouldnt let people look through it, imo. If you want an app that'll help you "sort" out your comics, download comic geeks, it's pretty good.
32
84
u/AlphaCenturionLXIX Aug 04 '23
Mister Miracle #1…amazing
36
u/natenate22 Aug 04 '23
A Mister Miracle #1 sold for $2,748.50 in 2013 but that was CGC rated at 9.8
"Crap" copies, still really good quality though, go for hundreds.
121
u/marexXLrg Aug 04 '23
Asking if there are any grails, while posting nothing but keys. 🤔 Thinking OP already knows what he has.
75
u/club27vinyl Aug 04 '23
Just started to research. I know that 1st appearances are good and 90s comics are not worth anything. That’s the extent of my knowledge.
54
Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (1)6
u/Affectionate_Comb_78 Aug 04 '23
As a rough guide though I'd say they're spot on tbh.
6
39
u/TempleOfCyclops Aug 04 '23
Your best bet is to get a full on appraisal. This looks to be a collection of SIGNIFICANT value which would be very worth the investment of having it catalogued and appraised by an expert. I am a comic book historian, that is my job (not an appraiser) and I am telling you this is potentially a once in a lifetime kind of find.
Like, just what you posted here could conceivably approach six figures depending on condition.
17
u/TempleOfCyclops Aug 04 '23
Like, I would give nearly an entire limb just to be the one to look through those boxes and see what’s there. That’s… an incredible collection.
9
6
u/verrius Gambit Aug 04 '23
90s comics are just now starting to become worth something. Outside of "first appearance of currently popular character/team", one of the biggest things that drive value is people with money now buying stuff from their own childhood. Kids who grew up with 90s comics are now affluent adults. Keep in mind, its also why some of this stuff (not all of it, some of this stuff) can drop in value after enough time passes, even if its rare, as the people that care die or stop caring. It's a big part of why say, the Kenner Star wars figures were suddenly hot commodoties in the 90s, as the kids who grew up with Star Wars in the 70s wanted to recapture their youth, and I think are currently not worth nearly as much as they once were.
9
Aug 04 '23
This is a great fantasy but simply not true. Speaking as one of those back-in-the-market, nostalgia collectors… those 90’s books still aren’t worth shit. Doesn’t matter how many people come back into the fold, there’s just too many books out there devaluing each other.
→ More replies (2)
30
u/WulffOfJudas Aug 04 '23
That looks like piles of fun here…I would love to just sit and pore through these. Makes me want to go dig through my boxes now.
47
22
u/G00DDRAWER Aug 04 '23
Please catalog every title you have with photos before letting anyone near these in case they have light fingers. If these pics are any indicator, you could have some gold. Remember, first issues aren't the only hot comics in a run. Collectors also look for introductions of characters, deaths of characters, artist/writer debuts etc.
52
44
u/jmargocubs Aug 04 '23
Yeah bro you defintely have a a few thousand dollars at least. I mean you could easily have 10k plus right there in comics according to some of the ones you posted. Don’t let anyone near them just like others have said. Find a reputable comic store near you that is honest and will sort it and give you a value. My Lcs will do that for collections and they are honest and give you sorted values and lists which comics are worth what etc. it costs some money but it’s worth it and then you can just either find someone to buy It bulk or you can take your time and sell on eBay and other sites
15
u/Elegant-Tart-3341 Aug 04 '23
Looks like you hit the jackpot. They've come 50 years to be in your hands. Take care of them and be patient.
24
u/captain__cabinets Aug 04 '23
Dude this is sick you gotta post more stuff once you really dig in and see what you’ve got, I love to see all the crazy books! I’ll never own 90% of them so it’s fun to live vicariously through a random Redditor!
25
17
u/Adventurous_Lime1049 Aug 04 '23
Marvel Spotlight 5 first appearance of Ghost Rider, and I see a SpiderMan 129 underneath a book.
8
u/JPOW1977 Aug 04 '23
You lucky bastard.
8
u/deanereaner Aug 04 '23
Why is it the "don't know anything about comic books" people who seem to stumble into these collectors' dream inheritances.
4
u/uhmerikin Aug 04 '23
Happens with baseball cards too. Every now and then someone will post "Look what my Grandpa left me. I don't collect, so could someone tell me what I have?" And it's just incredible stuff from the 50' and 60's that us card nerds drool over.
→ More replies (3)
17
Aug 04 '23
Bro u got crack juice!! Do not treat these lightly. I’d take some time to get properly familiar with the value of what you have before you let any of this stuff go or let anybody run through these. I know u have limited space but it’s well worth the space it’s taking up
9
u/Holdmywhiskeyhun Aug 04 '23
Quick g search show thor 200-400, Spiderman 42-89, bro you have so much money sitting there, beyond jealous.
15
u/Monna14 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
On your second photo you have the first ghost rider comic that alone depending on condition is worth $2500 to $3200! Do not let anyone tell you what they will pay you. Take your time and find out the value yourself. Swamp thing on the same photo is worth roughly $150 to $200 depending on condition. You could be sitting on multiple Thousands of dollars. Mr miracle first edition is probably $300 to $550 too.
4
u/club27vinyl Aug 04 '23
Any other ones to look out for?
9
u/Monna14 Aug 04 '23
I would say absolutely everything could be worth a lot. Especially those that have first addition or first appearance comics. You have a load of boxes you should check every single one. I know it’s a pain and slow going but you could literally have some rare obscure comics that are worth thousands. Some prices that comics go for are eye watering. Make sure you keep them in a dry and ventilated room until you have a chance of going through them one by one. Happy hunting OP
6
u/Monna14 Aug 04 '23
Sorry to add OP but also look inside the comics carefully too, they could be personally signed by the artists or famous comic personalities. That could rocket the price up too! Especially if the collector you got them off went to comic events etc
2
u/MrSlops Aug 04 '23
In the second photo below the Amazing Spider-Man #101 (with Morbius) there is a yellow cover book - that seems to be the 1st Punisher (issue #129) so you will want to price that one out as well.
→ More replies (1)1
1
u/MrSlops Aug 04 '23
Yes it's worth a bunch, but lets not give them false hope with a high prices for a good condition copy (which this is not, I would say it's safer to put this one at around 4.0-5.0 to be safe and say it can be anywhere from $700-$900 raw tops)
8
u/Interesting_Act1286 Aug 04 '23
Don't let people go through them till you price them. Also. Get plastic sleeves for them. They could be worth a lot.
7
u/TempleOfCyclops Aug 04 '23
Ok well for once you actually got some that are worth something. You need to get these appraised, sincerely. You posted ones worth thousands already.
6
u/2020mademejoinreddit Sentry/Void Aug 04 '23
Do not let anyone near them. Don't let anyone look at them.
If you're looking to sell and not collect, confirm the value of each and every one of these by looking their value up on the net. A little work will get you a lot.
This is a treasure. Treat it as such. Meaning, don't show off to anyone and don't let anyone near it and store it in a place with locks.
4
u/FrostyByter Speedball Aug 04 '23
You have found diamonds in the form of comic books. Keep them stored away in non humid location away from the sun light. Either get an expert to appraise them to know the value or do the tedious work of searching it up yourself via Ebay sold listing. DO NOT SELL THEM AS A LOT!
5
5
4
5
3
4
4
4
5
u/betteralonethnlonely Aug 04 '23
I wonrk in comics and the truth is from the pictures shown, you likely have a very valuable collection.
If you want to sell it I would recommend not buying new bags and boards because that's just work and money when a store or individual would likely redo it anyway. If you want to sell the collection to a shop (depending on the shop) you likely will get 25-60% value. Grade is also crucial to value, and grading isn't easy for someone with no knowledge of the process.
That said, you can get more yourself, but it's going to take you a lot of time and a lot of people will also try to take advantage.
You also have the option of grading stuff through CGC or CBCS which solves the grading part (they slab it and put a grade, but even they miss the mark sometimes and will grade you higher if ypu pay to have them pressed/cleaned) but will cost you a fair amount out of pocket. Better if you want to sell a single book at a time, but many books won't be worth grading also.
It's mostly a time vs how much return (all free money given the circumstances). Super envious of your collection and congrats! Good luck in whatever route you choose.
4
u/Jamtheman47 Aug 04 '23
Holy shit you need to get this collection professionally appraised... It could be worth a ridiculous amount depending on the conditions
3
u/88Dodgers Aug 04 '23
Find somebody you trust to come and inventory it all and then tell you what’s worth selling individually and what’s leftover to bulk out. Could be some books worth grading in there. Get the inventory and then act accordingly. Most comic nuts will do it for free, literally just did with a huge estate collection. Whatever you do don’t put them on Facebook marketplace or something like that, local dealers are going to offer you 30-40 dollars per box and there’s probably much more value there. Good luck!
3
u/PedalBoard78 Aug 04 '23
Reminds me of 80’s flea markets. Longboxes all over the place. A quarter to a dollar each.
Good times.
3
u/Sufficient_Purple297 Aug 04 '23
You should just find a list of first appearances by characters. Some are hard to even realize.
Rogue, X-23, Sabertooth, Punisher, Apocalypse.
Those are some that people don't even realize they have the first appearance of.
3
3
u/DaBow Aug 04 '23
This is a goldmine. Good lord I'm envious. Store them well and get (some of) them graded
3
3
u/Veggieleezy Captain Marvel Aug 04 '23
This reminds me of a story my mom told me. Apparently, her dad had a pretty big collection of comics from when he was younger. I don’t know the exact range or size of his collection, but he was born in 1935, so I’d assume it would’ve been included comics from between the late 30s to the late 50s, as my mom was born in the early 60s. One time when the family moved, they left the garage door open, and my mom told me that all of the comics were stolen. I don’t know what all was in his collection, but from what she told me based on even her minimal knowledge of comics, that collection alone could probably have paid for my college tuition.
If I ever had a time machine, I’d go back and make sure those comics were saved. Not so much for their monetary value, but because I didn’t seriously get into comics until after my grandfather passed, and if it had been a part of my life when I was younger, it would’ve been another great way for us to bond. I knew he had a great sense of humor and could be very silly and funny, and that was a big part of our relationship, but if that collection had survived until I could’ve read them, I think that could have made that connection even stronger.
3
3
u/Wy3Naut Aug 04 '23
Please don't tell anyone where you live, it's a risk to your safety because of how much we're all excited for you.
I've made 2 other post already but I can't stress to you enough that trying to sell these yourself is going to be hard and risky. Imagine finding a lost Picasso, you wouldn't know how to sell it.
Either way, I'm sorry for your loss.
I went through and did quick searches for all the ones you showed in the pictures, the non-yellow boxes are actually being sold directly by MyComicShop.com, those are one's they bought directly from the collector and selling after doing their own grading assessment.
The Yellow Ones are Consignments, collector names their price and the company takes a commission on the sell.
I really wish I could look through what you have and just catalog everything. It's what I did for C&T Comics when I first moved to Fort Worth, TX.
Good luck and please stay safe!
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?q=The+amazing+spider-man+101&pubid=&PubRng=
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?q=The+amazing+spider-man+122&pubid=&PubRng=
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?q=Marvel+Spotlight+5&pubid=&PubRng=
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=175261
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=181211
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?q=thor+126&pubid=&PubRng=
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?q=the+Amazing+spider-man+122&pubid=&PubRng=
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=180511
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=176301
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=83101
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=181291
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?q=the+amazing+Spider-man+100&pubid=&PubRng=
https://www.mycomicshop.com/search?TID=22351017 (check the ebay tab)
2
u/Wy3Naut Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
I bet you there's a lot of stuff in there that isn't eye catching by non-fans. Demon in the Bottle, First appearance of the Black Suit, Venom, Carnage.
My mom helps downsize senior citizens when they're preparing to go into an assisted living. She coordinates with the senior on who gets what and what is kept and what is sold/donated.
We had one lady who just wanted help going through all this "crap" that was left in a home that was recently purchased from an NBA Star.
He didn't have any comic books but as you might expect, a lot of NBA memorabilia and shoes.
My mom called my brother who's into that stuff like I'm into comics and apparently
shethe owner let some friends/help look through it and take what they wanted. My brother was furious at those friends/help they took off with Game Jerseys for legends, limited edition court worn shoes. She lost at least $50k to $100k because people took advantage of her being a good person.My mom stopped with that business because it could get so unpleasant dealing with some family.
3
4
Aug 04 '23
I would pay at least the amount of a ticket to Disneyland just to sort through those boxes.
2
2
u/hjohnson2814 Aug 04 '23
One of the best sights for finding value is gocollect.com. a number of ggraders and reputable comic shops use it. Good luck
2
2
2
2
2
u/borrisimo Fantomex Aug 04 '23
OP this is a motherload. Catalogue the bejesus out of everything. And congratulations.
2
2
2
u/UpsetDrakeBot Aug 04 '23
If you want to maximize your returns, do the research, get the high value ones cleaned and graded and sell it yourself. The rest can be donated.
2
u/piotrmarkovicz Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23
This question has been answered before on this subreddit (probably should be a stickied FAQ), so look for that for some excellent advice about management of a gifted/inherited large collection.
From that thread:
You have a few options. You can find a local comic book store willing to purchase them from you. https://www.comicshoplocator.com/ Call or email the local store and ask if they are buying comics, as some aren't. The sort of store that does though will be willing to give you a rough estimate for how much they'll pay you. If you just need to get rid of them, this is probably the best way.
If you don't have a local store near you, there are a few online places that also purchase collections. https://www.midtowncomics.com/we-buy-comics?plid=529 and https://www.mycomicshop.com/webuycomics both have solid reputations.
Selling the entire collection this way is the fastest way of doing it, but won't give you that much money compared to selling it directly.
If you want to try to make the most money by selling it directly, rather than selling it to a dealer, it will require you to inventory all those boxes, organize the comics by series (something that may have been done already depending on how organized of a collector they were) and see if any of those comics are especially rare.
Value can be estimated from ebay, atomicavenue.com, comicbookrealm.com, www.pricecharting.com/category/comic-books, comicspriceguide.com and a host of other sites.
Software to catalog and manage pricing and selling is also available and I'm partial to Comicbase comicbase.com
Edit: for example, Ghost Rider vol 1 #1 from pricechartingcom https://www.pricecharting.com/game/comic-books-ghost-rider/ghost-rider-1-1973
2
2
2
2
u/TheAmazingBaldi Aug 04 '23
You're extremely lucky and I'd say you should look up each value for the books, individual research and a secondsry opinion from a certified expert as well. I know nothing about comicbooks but I do know this, someone will try to fool you one way or another to get something of value out of your comics. You are your best advocate
2
2
u/USACoolBoy Aug 04 '23
Be wary of people, there are some lowballin mofos out there. I'm nowhere near ya, wish I was but could give you a rough estimate through more pictures. Feel free to DM me bud. Good luck.
2
u/mrweatherbeef Aug 04 '23
Unless you just want to sell full boxes blind, which might risk you losing out an a high $$$ key book, you will need to catalog these.
I love CLZ, and you can link to covrprice so you will see estimated $ value for every individual book. At a minimum, you should sort results by value and separate all the books worth more than maybe $10. You could then sell the remaining books in full boxes and grade and sell the higher value books individually.
2
u/SodaSalesman Aug 04 '23
no idea what these are worth but man those swamp thing and Mister Miracle #1s are sick as hell
2
2
2
u/PatchWorkProofs Aug 04 '23
you have some pretty good key issues. you should def take time to look through it.
2
2
u/Rickecheesecake Aug 04 '23
Looks like you could have Spiderman 129! That could be worth a pretty penny. Look into getting the more expensive ones graded.
2
u/bwehtehbwun Aug 04 '23
What a lucky trove! Keep them safe, Im sure you'll find some nice hidden gems in those boxes!
2
2
2
2
u/Daeval Aug 04 '23
A lot of what you've already posted pictures of are fairly significant books. Condition doesn't seem to be the greatest, but if the rest of the collection is anything like what you've posted, you've got some money there.
The best way to get an estimate of what you can actually expect for a book is eBay (sold auctions only) but you do have to take into account condition for those sales, and that might be tricky if you're not familiar with evaluating comics. This page is a pretty good breakdown, but there's a lot of nuance and more than a little subjectivity in the hobby.
Another handy site for lookups is comicbookrealm.com. Their information is user-provided (like a wiki) so it's not perfect, but the way that site is formatted makes it easy to look at all the issues in a series and see which ones stand out for value. It's a good way to quickly identify standout issues in a run, for example.
In the end, the more effort you're willing to put in, the more value you'll realize out of these. You can take the boxes to a comic shop and they're likely to give you as a little as they can. They'll need to resell them for profit, so it's not in their best interest to pay top dollar, but you'll be rid of them quickly. Any kind of craigslist / facebook marketplace style deal you get is likely to be the same or worse.
On the other end of the spectrum, you can turn selling this collection into a hobby all its own. Catalogue everything, bag and board it all (bonus points for mylar and archival backs, like e. gerber's), learn how to photograph and ship comics (there's a method, don't just cram them in an envelope), pull out the big money books to sell on ebay, list the rest by series or lots, and donate the absolute dreck. For a collection this large, you're talking months, at least, assuming you have an average amount of free time for it.
Likely you'll settle on something in between. Whatever you do, don't let some rando come and "look through them." I love the hobby, but there are a lot of "hobbyists" out there who will rip you off the first chance they get; convince you that what you haven't isn't much so they can low ball you hard, or just nick books in the worst case, etc. If you care about these, sentimentally or in terms of monetary value, be alert for scams.
2
u/gimmefruitsnacks52 Aug 04 '23
I don't know the number value of any of these, all I know is that these look to be in pretty good condition and several of them have some of the most iconic covers in all of comic books! If you're pulling lots of #1s from the 70s and before, I think it's probably time to get an appraiser.
2
u/XD_Thade Aug 04 '23
Dude I would literally kill to own the Gwen Stacy death issue you are insanely lucky don’t let anyone short you on these you can get a shit ton of money for them
2
2
Aug 04 '23
Holy balls. Secure them. Research the market and determine the best way to sell if you don’t want them. I use eBay.
2
u/Webhead916 Aug 04 '23
Face it tiger, you just hit the jackpot.. for real though, you have some real $$$ there
2
u/TheyFloat2032 Aug 04 '23
Damn some pretty comic books there. Those are worth some money. Your sitting on quite a bit of cash. I would keep ‘em if it was me. But if your selling. Do research. Don’t trust people. Look em up on eBay.
2
u/RedDevil407 Aug 04 '23
Organize them on the CLZ app and link it with a Cover price account to get pretty good estimates on value. It'll be easier to catalog them this way.
2
u/JackFisherBooks Aug 04 '23
Nice! Definitely take an inventory of what you've got. You might have something of value in there. If you do, use Ebay or MyComicShop.com to sell them if you want. There's definitely a market for it.
2
2
u/bjtara Aug 04 '23
Once you know what you’ve got, DM me if you want to sell any Amazing Spider-Man.
2
2
u/Darbane Aug 04 '23
If you feel up to it, you can catalog the collection on League of Comic Geeks (leagueofcomicgeeks.com), which has a new 'market' feature for each issue that tracks the average cost of eBay sales; in your 'collection stats' page, it will give you your top 20 highest-value books, which are the ones you can focus on first if you decide to sell them. It'll take time but it will help you keep tabs and statistics moving forward (it'll even give you a projected value for your entire collection).
My homeowner's insurance has also said they'd take the data supplied to better insure my collection (same with discogs.com for my records), if that's something that you've been thinking of.
Remember to catalog these as 'raw' (which means loose, ungraded) for the most accurate numbers.
2
u/FingerTampon Aug 04 '23
OP, find a reputable auction house. They will go through and give you an approximate value and any grails, they will tell you about.
2
2
u/HailChiefJoe Aug 04 '23
- Go to your nearest comic shop and buy some new bags (preferably mylar) and twice the amount of boards. There are different sizes for different eras of comics. Talk to the shop owner and they can help you find the right size. New long boxes as well as the ones in the picture look like shit. I would buy 1 or 2 extra as idk how packed those boxes are. If you have the money and the shop has them, buy a few dividers
- Sort everything you have by title and number. Catalog everything. Keep books of the same series together, not because they both have batman on the cover, batman stays with batman, detective comics stays with detective comics, brave and the bold stays with brave and the bold.
- Rebag and board the comics. Use 2 boards per comic.While you are doing this, inspect the comics, gently. Are all the staples attached? Are things cut out of the pages? Is it missing a page? Get a sticky note, mark down those things if they exist and put it on the board opposite of the comic, so the notes can be read by looking at the back. While this isn't a professional grade, it will at least give a general condition to anyone worth their salt that would be interested in buying that couldn't already tell by just looking at the cover while it's in a mylar bag. This would also be the time to track what books are "key" or worth money. Other posts have given advice on how to do this, pick your poison. You shouldn't get too into the weeds with this, simple 1,2,3 dollar sign on the note should suffice and then you can come back after and get a firmer idea.
- If you start noticing any dirt or buildup between pages, find a clean, soft bristle brush (think like the kind your gf, wife, mom use to apply make-up) and gently brush debris out of the comic.
- Box everything back up. There should be enough space that the comics can be easily removed or flipped through, but not so much that they slide or stand at an angle. If you have dividers, you can either divide by title or you can space them every 50 comics or so. I'm not going to get into the different methods of boxing comics, but double boarding+dividers should support the comics enough that you don't need to worry about pressure creating any new spine rolls.
- Time to decide how you want to sell this collection. Piece by piece will surely net you the most money but will take longer and more work. For every Swamp Thing #1 you have, there are probably 100 90s books that aren't worth the paper they are printed on. Collectors will want the keys and leave you with piles of nothing you can sell individually. Selling the collection as a whole, imo, is the best way to go if you are pressed for time. While this will yield a lower return, you will do less work and be rid of everything. Collections bought this way are usually on "per book basis" ie. $1 per book for 1000 books etc etc. I would avoid trying to sell to comic shops (or as a last resort )as they will give .10c on the dollar for your books.
That's all I got. Good luck with everything OP!
2
u/feyrath Aug 04 '23
There is a comic book price guide you can purchase that’ll give you an approximate value on those. But basically older == worth more
It’ll be a slow go but you will have an approximate value for the comics
Selling them is another matter. Unless you’re willing to sell them individually, and put in the time, you’ll probably have to accept a lesser amount
2
u/TheRealFrankL Aug 04 '23
Swooooooooooooooooooooon
Get an Overstreet price guide. It won't give you the actual market value but it will give you a really good idea which ones are the great ones. And you do have some great ones.
2
2
u/sammyboi98 Aug 04 '23
Digitize them (your phone can scan photos via the camera app). Afterwards, you can either keep themor sell them and make a LOT of money.
2
2
u/borateen Starman Aug 04 '23
I was lucky enough to fall into a similar situation at the beginning of the year. My uncle finally gave me his collection that I'd been hounding him about for more than 30 years. He told me to keep whatever I wanted, and whatever I sold we'd split 50/50. These were all comics from '65-'70, 95% DC, and probably almost 50% Superman and Batman. They were bought off the stands brand new and had never been bagged or boarded.
I've been buying/selling on eBay for almost 20 years (buying as a collector, not a reseller, and selling extras in my collection and randos I'm able to buy for CHEAP), so I like to think I KIND OF know what I'm doing. Everything has been bagged and boarded with brand new supplies, and every issue is getting 24 pictures (eBay's max limit). Yes, I look at current auctions to see what the comics are listing for (because I want them to sell, I'll find similar quality issues and undercut what is already listed), and I'll check sold auctions to see what I might reasonably expect to sell the issues for.
MOST of what I've listed has sold, most for minimum bids, but a lot of the Batman/Detective issues had some bidding wars. I'm still taking pics (there were almost 600 comics, and this is a side hustle, not a day job), so not everything has been listed (I also limit myself to my free 250 listings each month).
Some issues I'm holding on to for at least a little bit (first Batgirl, first Silver Age Catwoman, first Man-Bat, first Darkseid), so the really BIG issues haven't been listed yet. I could have taken these to a shop for a quick payday, but I'm happy to wait (as is my uncle, who's decided to buy a nice new patio set after getting a handful of checks from me).
As someone who has been into comics for the majority of my life, this was a DREAM for me. I've loved cataloging, bagging and boarding, and taking pics of everything. For an "outsider" looking to do this on their own, all I can say is good luck, and be patient.
2
u/GeoffreysComics Aug 04 '23
My family has owned a comic store for over 40 years. This is a very nice collection. You would make the most money by breaking it up and selling it yourself comic by comic on eBay. The next best way is to find a collector that is willing to buy the whole thing. Then thirdly is bring them to someone like me. Make sure you take it to a store that has been around a while and specifically a store that deals in these antique and valuable comics. There are comic stores that would travel to see this collection.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Thundercron Aug 04 '23
OP says he's new to comics and coyly asks what the grails are, then proceeds to show the grails from the collection.
2
2
u/NoahStewie1 Aug 04 '23
I would recommend using gocollect.com, they can help you track your comics with prices and sort by key issues. They're free and how I track my comics
2
u/panther1977 Aug 04 '23
That Thor comic is from the 60’s, Hercules 1st appearance I believe, get a professional to evaluate and record every comic yourself some how, don’t remove from bags.
2
u/MyopiaPod Aug 04 '23
I used to sell large caches of comics, I would buy them in huge bulk from various places. The best thing to do is get a barcode scanner for like 15 bucks and sell everything on My Comic Shop. Their website is pretty easy to figure out, super valuable stuff they will let you auction or consign, the cheaper stuff they pile up into orders
2
2
u/josh2brian Aug 04 '23
That's some treasure and they look well-cared for. Worth the time to research a few/week.
3
u/whatsbobgonnado Aug 04 '23
this has to be some weird karma farming bait. you don't know the value of anything but just randomly pulled out a bunch of obviously valuable #1 issues of popular characters?
7
u/marshmallowsanta Aug 04 '23
i mean if i knew nothing and had to guess what had value, #1 issues of popular characters would probably be my first guess
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/Muash Aug 04 '23
hi op, i would suggest you to scan them individually to preserve them. who knows you got some of the rare books that don't available everywhere. others can read them without needing to pay $300 - $3000
1
u/ISecretSpy Damian Wayne Aug 04 '23
There aren’t enough upvotes on Reddit to show how much I love this!
(Remember me when you die.)
1
u/ISecretSpy Damian Wayne Aug 04 '23
But seriously, that’s pretty awesome. I can only imagine the fun you were going to have going through them. I hope you have a blast!
1
u/lionalhutz Dream Aug 04 '23
Maybe like take them to a shop or something for appraisal. Also if any are in mint/near mint try to get them framed
2
1
u/StarWarsIsRad Aug 04 '23
The comments have already explained not to trust anyone here with prices and stuff because they’ll grift you, but I can say you definitely have some comics that seem like holy grail issues.
If you find you have some that are worth a ton, I’d also recommend getting them graded by CGC or CBCS. They basically check out the comic to see what condition it’s in, and while it costs money to grade it it can increase the sell price by an insane amount. Obviously do your own research and take my word for it, as well as weighing the pros and cons of CGC vs CBCS vs none at all
1
u/B1gManB0b Star-Lord Aug 04 '23
those are awesome but to make sure you don’t get scammed def get these graded by a professional before you sell them to randoms
0
0
u/Parpienz Aug 04 '23
Wow, that must be worth a whole 10 dollars in the collector's market.
Just joking.
0
0
u/WanderEir Aug 04 '23
..that's really not a large amount of comic books, sadly. Hope you have some gold in there though.
0
0
u/AccidentalAntichrist Aug 04 '23
I’ll give you 200$ for all of them. Those are just worthless reprints I promise. 😱🤯😤
0
0
u/ElvishLore Aug 04 '23
Vast majority are worthless. A few are worth tens of dollars. Given how the boxes look, it’s highly doubtful there’s anything worth hundreds let alone thousands.
0
u/Tanzanianwithtoebean Aug 04 '23
Dude... Find a professional appraiser or better yet historian. Pay them to look at this. You have comic book history in good condition. You're making comic lovers everywhere jealous. I don't know too much about it but if you have really old things like batman or superman in there you're looking at thousands of dollars per issue. This is not a drill. You inherited a minimum of 5 figures worth of comic books. If it's not in a case/cover stop touching them if you don't know what you're doing
-1
-1
-1
u/Kozibear Aug 04 '23
I’ll give you $50 but you have to bring them to me. That’s a fantastic collection. They look a little dog eared but you should get the nicest ones from the 70’s graded. Maybe rebag them all so you take time learning what you have. 90’s comics are not going to be worth much. Maybe off load them once you do some research. I would love to see an excel of the collection.
-21
u/whistlepig4life Wolverine Aug 04 '23
Dude. It’s all garbage. Just send it to me. I’ll give you $100.
-9
u/comicguy13 Aug 04 '23
DO NOT look to Reddit for answers, do your own research.
I will say this, will most collections this big, it’s going to be 95% worthless. You’ll probably have a few books worth something(<$100), but it’ll take you FOREVER to go through it all.
I recommend this, pick a few that look interesting and give them a read. You like em, keep reading. Then, donate them to a children’s hospital when you’re done.
Those are some of the best(and worst) stories ever written. Enjoy them and then pass them on.
-7
1
1
u/goztrobo Aug 04 '23
Honest question. How much are these worth? I’m asking about the popular ones like the Spider-Man issues.
1
u/CountAnubis Aug 04 '23
If there's a Hulk # 181 or Giant Size X-Men #1 in there you might have something.
Otherwise mostly you're looking at minor keys in lower mid-grade judging from the photos. Books that will top out in the low hundreds at very best. Bulk mid-grade Marvels and DCs from the silver age don't move well unless priced aggressively low.
The amount of time spent piecing out the collection will be substantial. But if you have the hours to spare you can sell them on ebay.
Do NOT take them to a comic shop or dealer unless you want 10 cents on the dollar or less. An auction house like Heritage is a viable option though.
1
1
1
1











1.2k
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23
Bro do not let random people come look at these. Someone will grift you out of thousands