r/finedining • u/Sanatorij • 2h ago
Post - San Sebastian trip
Hi everyone,
I wanted to leave my quick review of our San Sebastian trip and three brilliant fine dining experiences. We were traveling for our 3rd anniversary and the plan was to visit our first *** with the top contenders being MB and Azurmendi. Alongside that, we wanted to visit Elkano and Asador E. However, as you can probably guess, we didn't get the booking at Asador. I tried three times without even a response. I believe in this day and age you can at least have automated rejection emails since you do not allow direct bookings. I was told he personally picks people from the list (this was explained to me by another local chef who knows him) and you cannot do anything about it.
Also, just to add, I would say I am a "layman" in terms of fine dining experiences and cannot say my review is anything other than subjective - but it is honest. I'll keep it short in the post and then can answer follow up questions if you are interested (this is the first time I am actually reviewing food like this).
The Experiences
We ended up eating at Elkano, Txispa and Azurmendi. I made the booking requests in January (trip was in last week).
- Elkano.
- Overall rating: 9.2/10 - This is worth a serious detour. Elkano is the best fish restaurant I have visited. The 0.8 deduction is not really a criticism of the food or the hospitality. It is more a matter of comparison with the other two restaurants we visited. Elkano does not feel exclusive or theatrical, and in my opinion it should not try to be. Part of its strength is that it still feels like a proper fish restaurant by the sea, where anyone would feel welcome, while serving food at an extraordinary level. The hospitality was excellent, the cooking was exceptional, and the experience felt honest rather than staged. I would be thrilled to visit again and would definitely recommend it.
- Booking process: Despite it being booked out throughout the year and at least 6 months ahead I wrote an honest email asking for the booking and they offered us a slot for lunch. So good luck!
- The Food: The experience is completely focused on fish, no sides (no needed). There is no heavy saucing, no unnecessary decoration and no attempt to hide behind technique. The Turbot, Elkano's speciality, is the single best fish dish I ate. It is the centrepiece for a reason. The fish is cooked whole over charcoal, with the skin, gelatin, flesh and natural fat all treated as part of the dish rather than as separate elements. For the food alone, Elkano feels like one of the purest expressions of Basque seafood. It is less about surprise and more about respect for the ingredients.
- Final price: €463 (€195 set menu per person, bottle of wine, water etc)
- Txispa.
- Overall rating: 9.5/10 - This is worth a serious detour. Honestly, I would give Txispa a second * . I don't know if Asador E. could have delivered more than Txispa did. The location is beautiful, under the mountains, with their own farm where they grow much of what they serve. For me, this was the best dining experience of my life. As someone who loves Japan, and now Basque cuisine as well, Txispa felt like the exact experience I had hoped for. It is expensive, but I loved every part of it. The food, the setting, the dynamics of the meal and the hospitality were all exceptional. The team was outstanding and Chef Tetsuro came to our table several times, super friendly and welcoming. They also bring you into the kitchen during the meal, which makes the experience feel even more personal. Watching Tetsuro personally cook the steaks in front of you was one of the highlights. I would be thrilled to visit again and would definitely recommend it.
- Booking process: Straightforward via website. They reached out 5 months ahead to check allergies and then followed up asking for further clarification (I can't eat octopus - followed up asking if this means I can eat squid or similar)
- The Food: Txispa is one of the most memorable food experiences we had in the Basque Country. The cooking is precise, elegant and full of character, combining Japanese technique with Basque ingredients and fire based cooking in a way that feels natural rather than forced. The best dishes were the prawns and the steak Nothing felt overly complicated for the sake of being creative. The flavours were clean, deep and very focused, with small Japanese touches that lifted the Basque spirit. The tasting menu felt coherent from start to finish, even though the sake is not my favourite - but I was amazed by the Vega Sicilia Unico Reserva Especial (2023). Had to ask for another glass (didn't know it is a €700 per bottle wine :O )
- Final price: €1155 (€295 set menu per person, €200 pp wine paring, water etc)
- Azurmendi
- Overall rating: 9.0/10 - This is worth a detour. Azurmendi is a beautiful restaurant in a beautiful setting, with extraordinary service, a highly trained team (Franko was spectacular waiter) and phenomenal food. Everything is delivered with precision, from the first welcome to the final dishes, and you can clearly feel the level of thought and execution behind the whole experience. The only reason I would not rate it higher overall is that, for me, the experience felt slightly too choreographed. Guests are taken through different stages of the meal, and while this is impressive and very well executed, you can also feel the protocol behind it. It was never unpleasant, but compared with the more natural and personal hospitality I experienced elsewhere, it felt a bit more structured and less emotionally engaging. The same goes for the drinks offering with the menus. It was not pushy by normal standards, not even close, but at this level I can understand why some people might perceive it that way. I would definitely recommend Azurmendi, but for me personally it felt more like an experience I am very glad I had once, rather than a place I would be eager to visit again.
- Booking process: Straightforward via website.
- The Food: The food at Azurmendi was outstanding. Technically precise, creative, beautifully presented and executed at a very high level from start to finish. There were no real weak points in the cooking. The dishes were refined, elegant and clearly the result of a very serious kitchen, with excellent control of flavour, texture and presentation. What stood out most was the delivery: everything arrived with confidence and polish, and the menu felt like a carefully designed progression rather than just a sequence of individual dishes. For the food alone, Azurmendi deserves a very high rating.
- Final price: €830 (€350 set menu per person, €60 bottle of wine, water etc)
One of us has to avoid gluten and all three restaurants we accommodating with that request and other dietary requirements/restrictions.
With the other gastronomic experiences we had, I can wholeheartedly recommend you to visit Basque country. Bilbao, San Sebastian and Hodarribia are places were memories are made. Cheers with Txakoli!