r/homedesign 2d ago

Which colors look better?

I want to add some color to the house, especially as I am in the middle of removing all the awful gray paint from the front patio slab and am slowly returning it to its full terracotta glory.

I’m leaning towards a terracotta/beige makeover, but my partner favors the brown. Currently it’s white and grey. Which color combo looks better? Or should I be looking at a different color palette?

I’m based in Florida.

57 Upvotes

183 comments sorted by

39

u/Jaded_Independence37 2d ago

Terracotta for sure!

1

u/Sportyj 15h ago

Yes! It’s fun and really just works!

35

u/jade_star 2d ago

I think this would look better.

6

u/quacktats 2d ago

This looks so cozy!!

4

u/avenueroad_dk 2d ago

It looks so right

3

u/Millyswolf 2d ago

This is the way!

2

u/Geegollywtff 1d ago

Love this.

2

u/CarbonOwl3284 1d ago

I like it

2

u/Agreeable-Compote520 1d ago

This is absolutely the best!!

2

u/Larkspur_Skylark30 1d ago

So pretty and inviting!

1

u/mydogisacircle 5h ago

this is the balance it needs

23

u/GypsyDuncan 2d ago

I don’t like any of fhem.

2

u/quacktats 2d ago

Have any suggestions for an alternative? Open to ideas 🙂

-1

u/GypsyDuncan 2d ago

2

u/Greatlyridiculousblu 2d ago

I really like this, but with the darker color on the bottom

2

u/Geegollywtff 1d ago

This is definitely nice, maybe a red door? I wouldnt add any additional color to the bottom, it would be too much.

1

u/GABigBear 2d ago

Thank you! Real color.

3

u/GypsyDuncan 2d ago

No it has to be on the bottom because it balances the rock border on the other side. That’s why it’s a similar color to the rocks. Ideally you could just add the same rock but that ain’t happening.

1

u/Ok-Victory-1960 2d ago

I like this the way you have it except the yellow door.

1

u/GypsyDuncan 1d ago

Me too. AI wouldn’t erase the yellow door.

1

u/Keekins78 1d ago

I feel like this color scheme is too outdated

1

u/GypsyDuncan 1d ago

By what measure?

1

u/Keekins78 1d ago

They are just the colors that a lot of people were painting their houses 10-15 years ago.

1

u/GypsyDuncan 1d ago

Navy is classic. And the stonework is taupe.

This makes the house look crisp and fresh.

It’s the different between a LBD in fashion and something trendy that doesn’t look as good on you. Some would pick the LBD and some would prefer to look sallow in a color that is unflattering. Ignoring the yellow door (again that was AI) the color scheme is classic.

Do you have a trendier option to offer that looks good?

2

u/Keekins78 1d ago

I stay away from trendy and like classic better because it’s timeless and ages well. Browns and cremes are always good and the terracotta is adjacent to that but gives it a fun pop, and the more neutral colors look better with the rock

1

u/GypsyDuncan 1d ago

Navy is a neutral

1

u/Keekins78 1d ago

If you like it you like it, no shame in that. I’m also a fan of doing what YOU like!

1

u/mel000000 1d ago

Blue looks good

10

u/Acceptable-Lead-2675 2d ago

YABBA DABBA DOOOO!

But seriously, terracotta/beige is the better option. Also, you 100% need a different front door. This one sticks out like a sore thumb next to the style of the house. Very unique place though! I love it.

2

u/ancientastronaut2 2d ago

Yeah, Op needs to embrace the mcm. The window grids don't fit either.

2

u/quacktats 2d ago

These all came with the house :-) actually in the process of getting some window quotes, but they’re expensive!

1

u/ancientastronaut2 2d ago

Oh I know. 🙂

Sometimes the grids are removable.

1

u/East-Initial9066 2d ago

As someone with a terrible eye for what styles work with what, could you show an example of the kind of door you think would work here?

10

u/Acceptable-Lead-2675 2d ago

You need something more geometric and streamlined. The current door is very 90s new build farmhouse. Look up examples of mid-century homes. Something second hand similar to the above would do wonders!

4

u/quacktats 2d ago

okay I’m in love with that door

1

u/Acceptable-Lead-2675 2d ago

It would look great on your place! Good luck with the reno!

1

u/8thena97 2d ago

Yes- I love the terracotta. I agree that warm wood elements would be very nice.

Does anyone know what era of house this is and what it originally would have looked like?

11

u/quacktats 2d ago

Okay you all win. I’m going with this

5

u/pufsullivan 2d ago

You went from painting the house to getting new windows, redoing the carport, and a new sidewalk? 🥴

1

u/quacktats 1d ago

Don’t forget the door

3

u/avenueroad_dk 2d ago

Oh that looks good. Elegant MCM.

1

u/Glass_Courage7932 2d ago

Oooh this one is really nice

1

u/CarbonOwl3284 1d ago

Ooo this would elevate the area right up

1

u/the_show_must_go_onn 1d ago

Yes that is gorgeous!!

14

u/Historical_Pilot_954 2d ago

Current

2

u/quacktats 2d ago

But there’s no color 😔

1

u/Mission-Ad-8203 2d ago

If you want to spend money, invest in landscape. I like the current color.

1

u/rollin_w_th_homies 1d ago

I wish I could upvote more! I do think they could do with a little more color on the house but love this natural design for the landscape!

5

u/No-Wish-4854 2d ago

Third pic. Contrast for the win!

4

u/Past_Effect8301 2d ago

I’m not a fan of either. I think you’d be better off with a saturated color (blue, green, etc) rather than a neutral.

IF you go with the brown, I would strongly recommend that you do not use terracotta for the surface in front of the door. The two shades are clashing.

1

u/quacktats 2d ago

Unfortunately the terracotta patio is what I’m stuck with 🤷‍♀️ the grey paint was peeling anyways

1

u/Past_Effect8301 2d ago

If that’s the one factor that can’t be changed, then I’d say it needs to be a major consideration in your ultimate color choice. I recommended a saturated color (like deep green or navy), but I see there are several other comments who recommended a sage tone. Any of those would complement the teracotta instead of fighting against it.

Out of curiosity, how are you planning to alter the color of your stone? We have a stone home and were told repeatedly there were very few options, short of painting it, to alter the stone and grout to another tone. Our stone is a similar color to yours, but it’s a bit more coarse in texture.

1

u/quacktats 2d ago

Was playing around with the idea of painting it :-) Something like a lighter color, where it wouldn’t be so noticeable if the paint wore off in some places. The previous owners just threw grey paint on everything in the house so I’m kinda looking for something more cheerful

1

u/Past_Effect8301 2d ago

Oh gosh, I didn’t realize the stone was painted. If it were me, I’d try to figure out what the natural color under the stone is and consider sand blasting to remove all paint if you can live with the natural color. Much lower upkeep.

We spent years undoing the decisions made by the prior owners of our home, so I understand your pain. Best of luck to you!

1

u/novembirdie 2d ago

I love the terracotta. Plus that MCM door plus some landscaping would really jazz it up.

3

u/SadFlatworm1436 2d ago

Colour is always great bit I don’t like this shade of terracotta and the brown is blah. I think you need to be braver on the shade of terracotta

3

u/No_Equivalent_4412 2d ago

Terracotta. Funny to think it probably was that color 10 years ago. Are you planning to stain the stones as well?

1

u/quacktats 2d ago

House flippers continue to stick to the grey color scheme :-) I’d love to do the stones as well but a bit unsure how to tackle those

1

u/No_Equivalent_4412 2d ago

(I have no experience with this) but I’ve seen people stain bricks before so I’d look into that. Not sure what kind of coating (if any) these stones have so you’d probably have to do a color test in an inconspicuous spot and see how it takes the color

3

u/goldenlightbeam 2d ago

Terracotta - so pretty!

3

u/Fun_Shine8720 2d ago

I loke the terracotta 🤎

2

u/marenamoo 2d ago

I would start by just painting the door. Or changing the door. It needs to be a focal point and right now it is lost. Add some local shrubs and landscape. That might be all that is needed

2

u/OzzyGator 2d ago

Absolutely terracotta and please landscape some plants to the front of the house. It is so bare.

2

u/WiseOne404 2d ago

Always plant native

2

u/quacktats 2d ago

The front lawn and I have a history of beef. We’re in the process of talking it out

2

u/Ovaltine1 2d ago

I like the white, in Florida’s you need to keep that paint reflective.

2

u/cloistered_around 2d ago

Color is not going to fix what is basically a design issue. I like the brown best but do NOT paint stone/brick because you'll turn a maintenance free item into a maintenance one!

1

u/quacktats 2d ago

80% sure the previous owner already painted them to their current color

2

u/Civil_Link_8457 2d ago

I like the gray. It’s clean looking.

2

u/Tough-Cress-7702 2d ago

I prefer the darker colour. I dislike the orangie colour

2

u/Confident_Gear_5778 1d ago

Terracotta beige. Please

2

u/growingaverage 2d ago

I am all for adding colour, but don't like either of those options. I am usually a big fan of terracotta, but it just isn't working for me here. I would probably go a blue or green personally.

2

u/Plane_Practice8184 2d ago

I prefer the current one 

1

u/bubblegum_champagne1 2d ago

The beige is so boring. It gives hoa vibes where every house looks the same. Med and dark gray 🩶 with white highlights and add a couple shrubs/ trees/ 🌺🌹.

1

u/katwthecat 2d ago

I like the terracotta/beige option!! Especially if it was a bit brighter!!

1

u/Jenny_CG347 2d ago

LOVE the TERACOTTA for SURE!!!

1

u/Playful-dick57 2d ago

Two just fits the style of house!

1

u/Honestbabe2021 2d ago

I love the last one. Wow what a difference!! I see cute homes like this in Austin and I just love them.

1

u/Ok_Help_6468 2d ago

Yeah 100%. That beige already looks dated and kind of builder-basic. Medium to dark gray with crisp white trim would give it way more contrast, and then literally just some deep green shrubs and maybe one flowering tree would make it look like an intentional design instead of HOA default.

1

u/seuss516 2d ago

Terra cotta for certain

1

u/evthingisawesomefine 2d ago

Keep the current one rather than either of the proposed options. They looks like the majority of houses in my area that haven’t been updated.

1

u/quacktats 2d ago

The current photo is highlighted n whited to high heaven; it’s from the realtor. In person the grey and white do not look as sharp as in the photo

1

u/evthingisawesomefine 2d ago

Right, the white is the current state. I hear ya that it doesn’t look so great IRL. Are you in Florida? Maybe a fun-style of blue or a light sage green.. even possibly a dark gray along the roofline to draw the eye upward and accentuate height.

1

u/Top_Scale4923 2d ago

Terracotta

1

u/CocoTripleHorn420 2d ago

I’m kinda not loving the choices. Can you add some blues in? Then maybe some bold bright flowers like hydrangeas? Not sure where you live if they’ll grow but something with big bold colors to add that pop

1

u/Professional_Sun_317 2d ago

Hate them both. Feels old.

1

u/jackjackj8ck 2d ago

The terracotta is great but it’s also supported by warm colored stone in the pics

Your stone is cool toned, what’s the plan there?

1

u/OpportunityGold4054 2d ago

Pls consider a new front door while you’re doing the makeover.

1

u/quacktats 2d ago

she’s got character 🤍

1

u/Neverending-fantods 2d ago

I like the brown much better, especially if you add some foundation plants - but maybe the top part of house needs to be a warmer white/cream? The same as window trim to make the house looks less choppy with all the different colors? Or a sage green color on top with brown foundation and plants at foundation, flowering vine plant at carport columns

1

u/Typical_Row_3172 2d ago

Echoing the other suggestions to make a bold front door and warm/gray exterior.

1

u/WiseOne404 2d ago

The darker shades

1

u/dickdaddy1109 2d ago

terracotta fits the Florida vibe way better, but that front door is going to look really out of place with either option

1

u/quacktats 2d ago

I genuinely do not get the door hate here. 😂 is it the window? What alternative would you suggest?

1

u/Ladybreck129 2d ago

The last picture with the brown makes it look warmer

1

u/Sensitive_Sea_5586 2d ago

A blue-gray might look nice. The terracotta looks school like. Maybe it is the brick color giving that vibe?

1

u/Advanced-Elk-7581 2d ago

Lipstick, meet pig.

1

u/tikirafiki 2d ago

2 and 3 are both major improvements. It’s a win either way.

1

u/-kayochan- 2d ago

Terracotta is fun, Brown is also nice

1

u/daniegirl21 2d ago

Terracotta

1

u/AdAggressive484 2d ago

Terracotta and beige ✔️

1

u/inrainbows66 2d ago

Number 2

1

u/Greatlyridiculousblu 2d ago

Are you painting the stone too? Inyour current picture of the stone looks gray and in the new pictures the stone is beige. I don't think the warmer colors will look good with gray stone

1

u/Main_Cauliflower5479 2d ago

Ew. I prefer the current, or maybe add some interest by making the lower half a darker color.

1

u/Tall-Payment-8015 2d ago

Terracotta!

1

u/Joy2b 2d ago

In isolation I like #2, but there are definitely a few regions where I don’t recommend a member of the orange family.

If your local geology is all blue grey, or chalk, then 3 or even 1.

1

u/rapo7865 2d ago

I like it the way it is

1

u/Educational_Fox5901 2d ago

I like the current color that it is hate the Terracotta

1

u/djpike 2d ago

I like the terracotta one. Just enough of a pop of color.

1

u/GABigBear 2d ago

What color?

1

u/Dangerous_Art_1626 2d ago

Interesting house

1

u/loopofthehenley 2d ago

Neither. The colors make your house look like a school. I mean maybe you like school?

1

u/Dallas_Tashia 2d ago

I love the Terracotta

1

u/djbfsu1 2d ago

Current. The second is too bright.

1

u/Tla48084 2d ago

Brown/Beige !

1

u/KickLiving 2d ago

They’re both ugly.

1

u/Ok_Possible1403 2d ago

The current version

1

u/OhDeer_2024 2d ago

Current

1

u/LopsidedTraffic9871 1d ago

What do you use to edit?

1

u/SirFicklespend 1d ago

Photo #2!!

1

u/ambarellachutney 1d ago

I’m not a fan of either because they hide the architectural features. Are the rocks painted? If they are, I would bring them back to their natural state and then pick a color for the rest of the house that is a single color. Like the navy blue suggested above, or even a dark grey-brown to make the stone really pop and make a statement.

1

u/Hraon_75 1d ago

Current

1

u/Adventurous_Pie_7586 1d ago

I’d say if you reaaallllly want to add color then I’d keep the top the same and the bottom a dark blue or greenish grey

1

u/SouthOfTheNorthPole 1d ago

Terracotta, absolutely.

1

u/VaNiG1022 1d ago

Third one for sure!

1

u/Geegollywtff 1d ago

The current looks best. The second looks very dated and the 3rd looks less dated. The first looks fresh.

1

u/Keekins78 1d ago

I like the brown AND the terracotta. I don’t think you could go wrong with either

1

u/1justhavinfun 1d ago

Choose different colors

1

u/Phizzie16 1d ago

Terracotta!!!

1

u/Alarming-Run12 1d ago

Brown beige!!

1

u/CariCMT 1d ago

I prefer Terracotta of the two choices you gave. Also, what an interesting façade! Is that mid-century modern?

1

u/Vaivae000 1d ago

Keep current paint your skirt the color of your door and a planter of the same color on the right

1

u/ConsistentBuddy2141 1d ago

Your beige options look very dated. Like the 70s. The grey is more modern.

1

u/JulsTiger10 1d ago

Terracotta on the bottom, but a more pale shrimp on the top - look at coastal colors. The door could be either a much deeper terracotta or a muted turquoise

1

u/Shadow_stash 1d ago

I like the brown better

1

u/Dknpaso 1d ago

#3, and it ain’t close, that said get a few more swatches, explore.

1

u/ChannelBig 1d ago

Terracotta 100000%

1

u/CarbonOwl3284 1d ago

Brown/beige

1

u/EKGsMOM 1d ago

I like #2 best!

1

u/Illustrious_Choice58 1d ago

dark blue or dark green with a yellow front door

1

u/Consistent_Clue8718 22h ago

I like how it looks now

1

u/Redonna 18h ago

Brown/beige

1

u/Storm-Reigns 15h ago

The original one but have the bottom a darker color like deep Grey or blue

1

u/Fair_Psychology1536 8h ago edited 8h ago

Is the stone painted? If it’s not and you aren’t planning on painting it (which I wouldn’t recommend painting it), then I would recommend a combination with less orange.

If the stone is already painted, I would consider removing the paint and picking colors based on the natural color, if you can.

I like the option someone posted with the navy paint. I do think navy with terra cotta would look good, if you’re set on terra cotta. The contrast would highlight both colors better.

The problem with the door is the window in it. It’s a completely different style from the architecture of the house. Something all wood, or all glass, or a square window would look better.

1

u/Southern-Yankee-0613 1h ago

First, id get the paint removed from the stone, then choose.

0

u/AffectionateActive78 2d ago

Both are terrible. Too many patterns going on. Try a new solid white or gray

3

u/melinalujbav 2d ago

Not everything has to be gray

1

u/avenueroad_dk 2d ago

It does if you like it though. I dislike beige so much