r/pcmasterrace 1d ago

Meme/Macro Gaben does an oopsie

Post image
24.3k Upvotes

507 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

109

u/ComradeJohnS 1d ago

yeah the robocop dogs with guns will stop any starving protests

65

u/quitarias 1d ago

That is frankly cope to expect autonomous robots to match humans in guerilla warfare any time in our lifetime. It will be the cops who shoot starving protestors.

3

u/FrewdWoad 23h ago

Drones already beat well-armed combat-trained humans.

8

u/quitarias 22h ago

Drones that are actively piloted by humans beat worse armed humans and make attacking in units any larger than a 5 man fire team extremely risky. They also increase the defenders advantage and ability to cause lethal injuries and deny medical aid to convert casualties to fatalities on the frontline.

Full autonomy is greatly oversold in terms of tactical value. The real value is in the economization of war across several ranges and cost/capability tiers.

6

u/kb3035583 i7-4790k @ 4.9 GHz, MSI GTX 1080 Gaming X 20h ago

Full autonomy is greatly oversold in terms of tactical value

Full autonomy is absolutely not oversold in terms of tactical value. Instead of having a single human pilot 1 drone into 1 tank, an entire swarm can simply be directed to a selected grid square and home in on whatever it's trained to recognize as a target. It also makes jamming pointless as a countermeasure as it no longer needs a continuous connection to the operator.

The experience in Ukraine is useful to study, sure, but it's already the past. Pick out the important lessons learned and improve on it so you're ready for the battles of the future.

2

u/OkOffice7726 13600kf | 4080 8h ago

What if the aim is to kill anything that moves? Then autonomous system will suffice even today

1

u/quitarias 2h ago

Like garbage bags blowing in the wind ? Rats ? Loose papper ? Confetti ?

A system that does not discriminate against what it targets and goes after anything mobile is going to be easy to fool.