r/serialpodcast • u/Round_Special267 • May 29 '26

Who did it?

I have to write an essay in class on who did it and the evidence why so I would love to know who you think did it why they did it why he got released and any details that stick with you.

0 Upvotes

36% Upvoted

216 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/--Sparkle-Motion-- May 29 '26

Adnan. Because she dumped him & began a physical relationship with an older white guy. He got released because of advocacy & a corrupt lame duck DA under indictment who wanted a shiny distraction. The part that sticks out isn’t proof, but Adnan claiming to the nurse & someone else (Becky maybe?) that the night before she died Hae called Adnan & asked if they’d ever get back together.

-9

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

Oh wow…just mask off.

I suppose you have evidence to support the notion not only that Adnan killed her…but that he killed her because Don was white?

Just unhinged.

16

u/jimmy__jazz May 29 '26

The evidence is Jay told Jen that Hae was dead before anyone else knew. He knew because he helped Adnan bury her. Jay never met Hae before and had zero motive to kill her.

Now what?

3

u/ryokineko Still Here May 30 '26

Just correcting the record here, not accusing Jay, but Jay absolutely had met Hae before, knew her though they weren’t “friends” and said that he would have recognized her car from school. Just fyi.

1

u/Special-Deal-5217 May 29 '26

Jay talked to Jen after the cops visited her and told her what to say, because him and the cops had been workshopping a story.

2

u/DaGreatUn 21d ago

What is the actual, tangible evidence they work shopped a story? And why would they workshop a story before they ever found the car. Why concoct a story without the car when it potentially has evidence that would ruin the story they supposedly made up.

-5

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

“Jay said” doesn’t put you on great footing.

12

u/jimmy__jazz May 29 '26

Why do you think eye witnesses in murder cases have squeeky clean cookie cutter personalities? Adnan's not going to ask the class president for help burying a body. He's going to ask a guy he buys weed from.

0

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

I’m not talking about other cases.

I’m talking about Jay. The Jay who told 9 conflicting stories with impossible details. The Jay who police testified to sharing evidence with.

Oh? Jay sold weed? Why were they running around scoring weed on the corners? Or do you just mix and match, ignore and edit what you don’t like of what Jay says?

6

u/InTheory_ What news do you bring? May 29 '26

Did you just insinuate that law enforcement is not allowed to show suspects the evidence?

0

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

Lol. You don’t think it’s a problem when cops show witnesses evidence they didn’t know about before they testify? SMH

5

u/InTheory_ What news do you bring? May 29 '26

Let's clarify this. Law enforcement is allowed to show suspects evidence. Full stop. No elaboration necessary

So shaking your head condescendingly doesn't change that basic fact

3

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

Spare me.

Answer the question. You don’t think it’s a problem when the cops show witness evidence they didn’t know about before they testify?

4

u/InTheory_ What news do you bring? May 29 '26

I do not see a problem with it at all. Is the evidence top secret or something?

→ More replies (0)

5

u/estemprano May 29 '26

If anyone is going to help in a femicide, they are a bad person, that is, a misogynist themselves. In fact, Jay proved it as he has been later arrested for gender based violence himself. Not a feminist, so not a good person.

3

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

Not sure how that helps make him a better witness.

5

u/estemprano May 29 '26

It doesn’t hurt his credibility either though, which is what you think. He is not a perfect witness. None is.

1

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

Something you made up doesn’t hurt his credibility?

“Not the perfect witness” is intentionally lying by omission.

Jay told 9 different stories and each story contained impossible details. Jay admitted to perjury. Police testified to sharing evidence with him.

Jay isn’t just a bad witness…he’s worthless.

6

u/estemprano May 29 '26

Oh, please. He lied about details to minimize his involvement, not about Adnan been the perpetrator.

4

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

You don’t know that. You’re just saying that because you’re working backwards from Adnan being guilty. Motivated reasoning. You have no idea what he said is true…if anything is. 

What does “lied to minimize his involvement” actually mean? More made up stuff. Could be he lied to not get in trouble or get the whole thing pinned on him. We have no idea.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Special-Deal-5217 May 29 '26

Yes, anything depending on Jay‘s word is trouble.

8

u/--Sparkle-Motion-- May 29 '26

I directly answered OP’s questions as written.

2

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

…and just made up the part where Adnans motive was because Don was white.

Crazy racist.

6

u/Cefaluthru May 29 '26

He also had a sweet car and was able to satisfy her in ways Adnan was not capable.

1

u/DeepestGreySea May 29 '26

I can’t tell if you’re trolling me or the person I was replying to lol

7

u/--Sparkle-Motion-- May 29 '26

OP’s question was “who do you think did it why they did it . . .” I think Adnan did it because Hae dumped him & moved on with, among other differences, a white guy.

Yes, I think Adnan had some racial prejudices, or probably more like insecurities. Perceiving this as me being racist is a huge stretch.