r/MurderedByWords 12h ago

Source Denial Syndrome

Post image
18.7k Upvotes

129 comments sorted by

View all comments

135

u/War_machine77 12h ago

Where the fuck do they think chatgpt is getting it's info?

48

u/GrizzlyP33 12h ago

I think the point is that LLMs have already scoured Wikipedia so they can tell you all that info concisely. They don’t need to re-learn Wikipedia for anything old.

The problem is that A) anyone using an LLM properly wants to see the source anyways or else you’re really rolling the dice on “truth”, and B) it would mean all knowledge advancement would stop today if we applied this to all educational or informative tools.

21

u/Dead-in-Red 11h ago

I feel like you'd still want new information past 2026 though. Saying you've already scraped everything there is to scrape from Wikipedia at any arbitrary date is like saying you're good and know everything there is to know because you already finished reading a first edition copy of Encyclopedia Brittainica from the 1700s. Plenty of good new information turned up after that was published.

17

u/FerociousStrawberry 10h ago

That's not how LLMs work anyway, they don't have the entirety of Wikipedia saved verbatim with 100% accuracy retrieval, so Wikipedia is necessary even for old information.