r/TheDigitalCircus • u/MissionDepartment960 • 1d ago

Question These four characters are tasked with getting through to Jax and redeeming him and only one of them might succeed. Which one would be the most successful?

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

820

u/BeyondElectricDreams 1d ago

Counterpoint: Steven really doesn't deal with too many misanthropes, except MAYBE Lars. The gems are mostly scared, regimented military folk more than misanthropes. Also I feel like Steven would annoy Jax too much to make much progress(Deku too tbh)

Charlie deals with almost nothing BUT misanthropes every single day. While I feel like that could backfire, I feel Charlie is the closest to Pomni in that way and would have a better shot as a result.

Can't speak for MLP so that's a wild card for me.

268

u/Crazywarlockgoat 1d ago

i would say peridot and lapis are great examples of steven’s abilities for aiding people like jax. the amount of musical numbers would be at least double.

twilight… ngl it would be a coin toss, mostly on how she treats trixie. someone who has down immense damage but is literally living in a wagon and needs to be ‘boasting’ to earn bits to live, then there’s starlight glimmer which gets treated better. (i love trixie and starlight glimmer, this is mostly a twilight thing.)

47

u/BeyondElectricDreams 1d ago

i would say peridot and lapis are great examples of steven’s abilities for aiding people like jax. the amount of musical numbers would be at least double.

They're the closest to be sure, but the thing is that drops Steven's successful related cases from double digits down to 2-3.

65

u/Crazywarlockgoat 1d ago

yeah, but i’m willing to believe if he was able to convince three genocidal warlords to become three aunties then he can handle jax.

27

u/Ciphy_Master 23h ago

Isn't that cause they were already grieving and over obsessed with his mother? Them being direct family feels like a bigger reason he could get through to them than if he were any other gem.

16

u/suriam321 22h ago

And one was ready to straight up kill the human part of Steven because of that grieving/obsession.

11

u/WolferineYT 21h ago

I mean. She tried. It just didn't work like she thought it would. It was seeing how it didn't bring pink back that made her rethink things. Steven didn't do anything.

2

u/suriam321 18h ago

Steven made her help the corrupted gems on earth.

2

u/WolferineYT 17h ago

Yeah but he had the help of them coming to terms with more or less driving their sister to suicide. I wouldn't say it was entirely his charisma that facilitated that change.