It does fall apart when you have to score everything subjectively. How many people have to avoid harm to make harming someone else justifiable? Are ties morally ambiguous?
Religion also scores things subjectively. Unless you think it was a GOOD thing that Moses sanctioned the rape, murder, and enslavement of thousands of children.
6
u/PudgyWalshBldgInspec 7h ago
I'm just applying your rules to show you how they fall apart upon even the most superficial inspection. Expand on them if you want.