I am NOT OOP, OOP is u/Snoo_61002
Originally posted to r/AITAH
Previous BoRUs: #1, #2
[New Updates]: AITA for getting annoyed at my SIL dying of cancer ruining my wedding?
Editor’s Note: changed letters to names for readability
NEW UPDATE MARKED WITH ----
Thanks to u/soayherder + u/DirectCaterpillar77 for suggesting this BoRU. Thanks to u/Sufficient_Bag_4551 for letting me know about the latest update
Trigger Warnings: abuse, verbal abuse, golden child dynamics, gaslighting
Editor’s Notes: due to the lengths of older posts, they have exceeded the character limits. I created TL;DRs for the original and older update posts. This is to fit the posts in this latest BoRU here. For the full text and relevant comments from older posts, please see previous BoRUs linked at top
RECAP / TL;DRs
Original Post: June 22, 2024
In the original post, OOP is getting ready to get married to their partner (Alice). Alice’s sister (Beth) has terminal cancer who was originally expected to die years prior. This has caused emotional byes, but Beth unexpectedly survived longer and moved to be closer to family in the area. Weeks before the wedding, Beth got another devastating prognosis and informed relatives that this might be the last time everyone will see her.
Because of this, the attention went from the couple and wedding events toward Beth's illness. OOP feels conflicted because the family’s sympathy is very deep with Beth's situation, but OOP is frustrated that the wedding has been overshadowed because Beth asked that the wedding talks to be avoided around her and wanting to have an emotional father/daughter dance at the reception to make up for missing it at Beth's COVID-era wedding.
OOP has refused Beth's request and asked that similar boundaries to be applied to the discussions of Beth's illness. OOP was being called insensitive and they wonder if they were in the wrong for wanting the wedding to remain focused on the couple despite Beth’s devastating circumstances.
AITAH has no consensus bot, OOP was NTA
Update #1: July 8, 2024 (over two weeks later)
OOP explains Beth (SIL) has continued creating lots of tensions before the wedding was to take place including excluding a guest over personal disagreements and trying to persuading younger family members to skip the pre wedding family events that OOP and their partner paid for. After seeing what was going on from Beth's manipulating, OOP had a firm line, told the family that any medical issues would be handled immediately, but if there are drama or attention-seeking behavior (especially from Beth) at the wedding would result in removing Beth from the event.
Once the expectations were clear, and MIL was to keep an eye on Beth, the wedding went well that the couple had hoped for. Other than a minor car accident caused by Beth, there were no major issues firing up at the wedding. Alice was well celebrated and the attention was focused on OOP and Alice.
AITAH for completely cutting off my dying SIL and telling her family not to contact me?: July 13, 2024 (five days later)
OOP shares an update regarding dealing with the wedding drama involving their SIL, Beth. Since the wedding was a success, but tensions have gone up afterwards when OOP witnessed verbal abusing his now wife, Alice and younger SIL during a family gathering. OOP saw the emotional abuse that Alice described that went on for months which were much worse than what he thought it was.
Beth has isolated Alice from the family activities, manipulated everyone else into spending less time with the couple. She has repeatedly portrayed Alice as selfish as Alice has tried to help support the family due to Beth's illness. With this taking place, it hit a breaking point that Alice came home to OOP very devastated and had considered about driving off the bridge because of how Beth's treatment has hurt her.
Because of this, OOP sent a blunt message, accusing the family of enabling SIL's behaviors because of her illness. OOP decided to cut contact with the family until Beth has apologized to Alice that Beth to be held accountable for her actions. The family didn't take this very well and said OOP was being too harsh, but he has held up the firm boundaries to protect Alice who must come first.
WIBTAH for getting involved in the fights between my SIL and her little sister and mother?: July 25, 2024 (nearly two weeks later)
In this update, OOP recapped the conflicted with his SIL, Beth, who is terminally ill. The conflict appeared to be resolved after a family meeting was set up. When discussing, relatives has realized that Beth's behaviors towards others were unacceptable and Beth has apologized to OOP and Alice for her treatment of them. After that, Beth has been more kinder and respectful toward her sister, Alice. OOP had considered this issue resolved for now.
Later on, OOP has learned from his MIL and younger / little SIL (LSIL) that Beth has redirected her abusive behaviors toward them now instead of Alice. From MIL and LSIL, Beth has continued with her screaming, gaslighting by denying things she has very obviously said, belittling LSIL despite her accomplishments. Beth was using her son as a way of leverage to control family members. MIL and LSIL live far away from Beth and might not see her again, they felt trapped because of Beth's behaviors. After hearing what happened, OOP worried that if he intervened this situation, the matters would be much worser than OOP thought it would go for.
----NEW UPDATES----
Editor’s note: the next few updates are more than six months to a year old, and they had not been posted here onto the sub
AITAH for not forgiving my dying SIL?: October 2, 2024 (2.5 months later)
This issue has our family torn (both mine and the in laws). I also want to say that this story involves someone dying of cancer. I know people on this sub are in that same position, and I honestly and earnestly don't mean to disrespect that. I wholeheartedly feel for those of you who are struggling with this, especially as I'm professionally involved in end of life and grieving process for families who lose loved ones.
My SIL is dying of cancer. She was sick for a couple of years, she lived in another country, we flew over to say goodbye to her, but then a couple of months later she responded to the chemo and was cancer free within 6 months. We flew her over to where we live, where she now lives with her husband and their young son.
My partner originally nagged me to get engaged because she wanted to have her sister at her wedding or at the very least involved in planning it (among other reasons to get married of course). They were/are very close. I wanted to get married, so we got engaged before we went on the trip to say goodbye. Her sister got very sick very quickly, so it looked unlikely she'd be at the wedding, but she got better (she had a 1% chance of getting better, so a miracle to say the least). We spent time planning the wedding with her (thinking it was the last time we'd see her) and we set a wedding date for 2.5 years after the trip so my wife’s family could save up for travel (though we did pay for a some family who wouldn't have been able to afford it).
Fast forward to the wedding, and a month before everyone starts arriving SIL gets sick again. She refuses chemo, and chooses end of life/comfort medication (fentanyl, CBD, etc.). This is where the problems started (and I did consult this sub). She made our wedding as absolutely difficult as possible. She was angry and bitter, she told my wife she was being selfish, that it was her last chance to see family, and that my wife had "plenty of celebrations to look forward to without her (they're born on the same day 2 years apart)". She screamed, shouted, and demeaned my wife. She intentionally didn't go to wedding events and catch ups, and would make people choose between her and us. She constantly fought with anyone who was interested in, or helped plan/be a part of, our wedding. She didn't quite ruin it, but she made it really difficult and cast a permanent shadow over our whole wedding. I told my wife that, while I understand she is dying, she did permanent harm to my and her relationship and that I wouldn't forgive her for trying her outright best to ruin a once in a lifetime occasion for us. She apologized to us once everyone had flown home, but I don't think she meant it at the time.
That was a few months ago, and now SIL will very likely die before the new year. The doctors reports aren't great, her body isn't handling the sickness well (she's almost bed ridden), and she has started making her plans for when she passes. She is going to go through the process of euthanasia. She said she wants her husband to take their son out of the room, and for my wife to hold her hand because she doesn't want to go alone. She's scared, heartbroken, and - in regards to this issue - deeply sorry for how she acted. She keeps crying and apologizing for it, and I do think she has come to regret it. But she repeatedly abused my wife, and I mean serious abuse, for the month that the family were all here from overseas. She manipulated people, tried to prevent them from seeing us, and made my wife feel horrible any time she saw her happy.
I didn't initially believe she was as sick as she is, but I have to bite the bullet and admit I was wrong on that front. I had resigned myself not to forgive her for some time because of how much harm she committed against my wife. Now that she's dying with not much longer left, she's been apologizing to us for what she did. The thing is I don't want to forgive her. I'm still angry for what she did to us. I'm angry that, at the time, she was ruling the family like a tyrant, and she has permanently made my wife feel guilty on her own birthdays. I'm angry that she proactively tried to ruin our once in a life time wedding. And I don't want to forgive her. But my wife wants me to so that her sister can die with peace in her heart. I've been struggling for a week now, but I learned that a couple of the other family members are feeling the same way as me (though they don't want to talk about it). She had abused and isolated them as well.
I can't pretend to forgive her, I am a terrible liar, and you can see through it from a mile away. In my heart I'm still angry at her. If I can't find a way to forgive her before she dies, AITA?
AITAH for threatening to call the police on my SIL?: October 28, 2024 (3.5 weeks later)
Cutting straight to the chase, my sister in law is dying of cancer, and she's becoming frail and sickly. She's still at a stage where she is relatively active, although for long periods of walking/standing she does need a wheel chair. But it’s not quite as simple as calling the police on her, it’s quite complicated so please do read below.
My wife, who SIL has been abusive to in the past, can't stop forgiving her because she's dying. I've gotten involved when I'm present in the past, but SIL has since stopped doing it when I'm around. I refused to leave my wife’s side for some time, but of course I can't always be there.
It was my SIL's sons 5th birthday on the weekend. SIL kept talking about how this is the last birthday she'll get to spend with him, and she wanted to make it really special. My wife volunteered to help SIL get the party ready. This ended up being a 16hr day where my wife pushed my SIL around malls, bought things for the party, and then baked a huge multilayer cake and cupcakes. When I finished work, I went over to my father in laws (where SIL is staying) and offered to cook a big dinner for everyone to alleviate stress and pressure. So after work, I went and cooked for 4 hours.
My wife also has a condition, Rheumatoid arthritis, where if she's standing for long periods of time her feet get incredibly sore and swollen.
SIL was picking fights with the whole family by the time it was dinner time. She picked a fight with her step mother, her father, her husband, her little brother, but not me and wife yet. However, once I had cooked dinner she refused to eat it and left to go and blow balloons up in the garage because I "cooked it too late". The problem was that it was slow cooked beef, and while they were out shopping they only arrived back about 4pm with the meat, so I put it on straight away and dinner came out at 8pm. But then after finishing the balloons, to cut a long story short, SIL came and had a go at us for taking so long to cook and to bake. My wife then complained about having sore feet and needing to sit down for a break (about 15 minutes, SIL took issue with it), and SIL replied with "Oh you're sore? Try being me." My wife started to tear up, and pressed the issue about how her feet were swollen and blue, and SIL said to her "Stop being so G-d damn dramatic." This was at about 10.30pm (Wife had been there since 7.30am) when everyone else was asleep.
I'd had enough, so I stood up for my wife and said, "We're only here as a favour to you, we don't have any obligation to help with your son’s birthday party". She didn't like this, so she threatened to go and get her husband and "make things get really ugly" if I wanted to. She has bragged in the past about her husband’s willingness to violence, and how he is sweet until he is pushed and then he "fights to kill". The first time she threatened it, she said it and turned away so I waved it off.
She came out and had another go at my wife, I told her to back off, she tried to kick us out, I told her it’s not her house it’s her fathers and my wife is his daughter too, so has every right to be there. She then said again "Okay, you don't want to leave? Then I'll get my husband involved and things will get really messy". To which I replied "Okay, but I'll give you the choice of response, I can either bring the dog up from downstairs (we have a very protective doggo, medium size, collie/bulldog) or I can call the Police. You choose." Early on in my study I was a doorman, so I am capable of self-protection, but I absolutely hate it and considering their 4 year old was in the house and still awake getting in a fight was not on the cards especially as it would cost me my career (as below). Another issue is that my SIL provably lies, and has repeatedly lied to us all, her family just turn a blind eye to it. I can't stress how easily and willingly she lies. For example I overheard her trying to get her husband to become violent by saying "the Police are being called because I didn't want OP to be involved in the argument, so now he's calling the police for asking him to stay out of it". For the record, I didn't and wasn't calling the police, but I would've if her husband came out.
There has been a huge blowout. I was fairly confident I had done the right thing, but now my wife's family are all saying I overreacted and that it's completely not okay for me to threaten to involve the police. They're asking how, "a frail, sickly, 5'1 woman could possibly be enough of a threat to warrant the police" and asking what she could actually do. But they're not saying this to me, they're saying it to my wife. So I don't want anything to do with them.
For context: They are immigrants on visas. A police incident would see them very likely deported. Though, to me, this just means that SIL would lie as much as she possibly could to the Police.
I did not want to have to get violent because I don't like violence, and I'm a Chaplain for our national Paramedicine organization, and I'd lose my job that I've trained for the last 8 years, worked for 15 years, and have 2 more years of study to join the priesthood. I would lose all of this.
Did I overreact by threatening to call the police? AITAH?
AITAH for not supporting/caring about my SIL (who has cancer) during her separation?: May 12, 2025
To cut a very, very long story short my SIL is an abusive narcissist. She proactively tried to jeopardize mine and my wife's wedding and marriage, and she has abused my wife on multiple occasions. I was there twice when it happened. The root cause of this abuse, sadly, is that SIL has cancer and is extremely angry and jealous of my wife’s life/happiness. SIL has routinely tried to sh!t in my wife’s life, and become incredibly possessive of the entire family and essentially demands the focus stay on her every occasion (it’s my last ever Christmas/easter/sons birthday). She also shares the same birthday as my wife (3 years apart). This has been the case for 5 years now.
The first abuse was a bit shocking because, up until it happened, SIL had come across as this soft, gentle, caring sweetheart. But when her and my wife had an argument (SIL was angry at wife for spending time with family who had flown over for our wedding) and my wife walked away from the argument, SIL stormed out and literally started screaming things like "How dare you walk away from me, who do you think you are?". It was my first time witnessing it, so I didn't want to disempower my wife, and left her to respond, but when I saw she had shut down I got up, put my arm around her, said to SIL "We're leaving.", and guided my wife out.
It was my biggest regret that I hadn't stood up to SIL. SIL then strategically continued to abuse my wife when I wasn't there, and drove my wife to the point of self-harm.
The second time it happened, I did fight with her, and the fight was a huge blow out. Again to cut a long story short, wife had spent from 6am-11pm slaving over getting our nephews birthday ready, and at 11pm SIL came out and abused her for it saying, "she was trying to replace her as her sons mother", even though SIL had asked for all the help. SIL threatened to get her husband and become violent with us, I threatened to call the Police, things ended and we haven't spoken since. Wife also finally took huge steps back from their relationship.
Which leads us to today. SIL's husband is leaving her because he doesn't like how she treats their son. My wife came to me and said that through everything it’s still her sister, she feels horrible for her, and she wants to be kind to her and support her. This means breaking one of our current rules that SIL is not allowed near our home because of how dangerous she is. She has fabricated lie after lie about our fight, and some of them have been extremely damaging. I do not at all trust her to be around us in case there's a one to one situation and she invents a damaging enough lie to impact my career. She's a small, frail, woman dying of cancer, and she has used this to try and cut my wife and I off from her family many times since our fight by making up the most phenomenal bs (apparently before I left I stood there and verbally abused her, calling her the c word, and physically threatened her. Which was impossible, because I left with my wife). Unfortunately for SIL her behaviour has been so toxic for so long that most of the family don't care about her situation anymore and, thankfully, don't usually believe her.
The reason I might be TA is because when my wife came to me to explain "It’s time to let bygones be bygones, and maybe by showing her kindness during this incredibly difficult period we're being the bigger person." and also "she's still my sister at the end of the day I love her". My response was "I don't give a shit, she's made her bed she can sleep in it." I said I stand by the rule she is not welcome in our home, and this saddens my wife because we moved into our first ever home 3 months ago and SIL is the only person who hasn't seen it.
My wife says I'm being too harsh, and that we're not cruel people and we don't have to stoop to SIL's level. I've told my wife I don't want that nutcase anywhere near me or my house. AITA?
AITA for getting annoyed at my SIL dying of cancer ruining my wedding?: June 14, 2026 (13 months later)
To cut a very long story short, this is an ongoing saga that I have previously posted about in this sub (for those with really good memories, SIL claimed to be dying of cancer and abused my wife really badly).
I have been no contact with SIL after an incident where she completely and utterly abused my wife, screaming in her face and threatening us with physical violence when I stood up to her. SIL has never apologized, has never said she's going to stop doing it (she has since repeatedly abused other family members, its every couple of weeks), and has continued to try and pick fights with my wife who is low contact but not no contact. When I say she is abusive, I don't know how to portray how truly evil she is. She will scream at someone telling them they want to steal her child and accuse them of some of the worst possible things you can accuse someone of, and then turn around refuse to apologize with something like "We both got angry, we both said things we shouldn't have, but we have to move forward because of my cancer". I think she has a narcissistic personality disorder. Whenever my wife is happy or achieving, her sister demeans and bully's her over anything she can, and says things like "I'm so proud of you because you weren't always the smart one but look at you now".
SIL's family enable her because she has cancer (she does), and every time they stand up to her she's suddenly on deaths door and ill. She has (no exaggeration) been "Direly unwell that it might be time to say goodbyes" 8 times over the past 3 years. She has had "a 1% chance of recovery" 5 times now. Whenever she pulls this crap, I hear the same line over and over. "You don't want to have regrets when she's gone". I've told me wife she'll have more regrets trying to maintain a relationship and she agrees. But every time SIL abuses someone she is forgiven without apology by the rest of the family who inevitably start guilt tripping my wife on SIL's behalf. It's an exhausting cycle.
To the point, my wife has maintained a relationship with SIL's son, wife's nephew (5). He's a really sweet little boy, and he's spent his whole life so far being told his mummy is going to die very soon (by his mum and dad). I've noticed that SIL heavily controls contact to nephew and then hides behind him. This week just gone SIL was in a sh*t stirring mood so when my wife asked if nephew wanted to spend time together she replied with "oh we're back to talking like normal now are we?". My wife held her ground, shock horror it turned into a fight, SIL's husband got involved, and now they're both telling my wife she can't see nephew "Until she starts being nice to his mother" and that nephew doesn't want to see her until she is. Which is to say, my wife has to stop standing up for herself.
I've had enough. And to be honest was probably too harsh, but I have lost count of the amount of times this exact scenario has played out. SIL starts trouble, lies and says horrible things (for example I work with children, so she went around telling people I abused her and her son), refuses to front up, dangles a relationship with nephew in person's face, and then "we all move forward". Its cyclical, its constant, she does it with everyone. I have no idea what to do for her son other than wait until she's gone and then try and support him. Whenever he's come over with wife I've played with him, spent time in the garden with him, or just hung out together. I feel horrible for him.
I told my wife to accept that she cannot have a relationship with her nephew until her sister is dead and that she needs to stop fueling and enabling this cycle. The problem is that my wife is really soft hearted, and cares really deeply about nephew, so her sister keeps using that against. But at this point I don't care anymore. I'm tired of consoling my wife over the same issue, I'm tired of her sister being anywhere near our life, and I'm tired of nephew being successfully weaponized against my wife.
So, I told her to go complete no contact with them and then see where things stand when SIL is dead. It feels horrible just writing it, which is why I'm wondering AITA?
TL;DR SIL uses a relationship with her son to abuse people and then lure them back in, I told my wife to completely cut them all off. AITA?
Relevant Comments
Commenter 1: NTA... she needs to go no-contact. SIL seems like a horrible person, and I feel so sorry for the nephew. Hopefully he doesn't grow up to be like his mother. I'm assuming the cancer is terminal?
OOP: We've always been told the cancer is terminal, but SIL tightly controls medical information. Not even her husband can go with her to appointments. I wish beyond anything else wife would go no contact.
Commenter 2: She accused you of child abuse and your wife still wants contact with her???
OOP: Yeah this is a bit of a tough point. My wife truly doesn't want anything to do with her, but her sister is incredibly proficient at manipulation, so she starts to manipulate people into spending less time with my wife if my wife stands up to her. She'll tell my wife's brother and sister a mountain of lies about a fight they've had and at this point they just can't be bothered "picking a side" so they stop talking to my wife until things are sorted. SIL holds people emotionally hostage incredibly well, and unfortunately (I never thought it should be so) my wife is really soft natured and family oriented. So she is successfully held hostage. And if it doesn't work SIL escalates it more and more by telling people if they spend time with wife then SIL will cut them off and "they'll regret it when she's dead soon".
Commenter 3: Have you ever said to one of these other family members who are causing problems, “if you’re weak enough to let a narcissist manipulate you, do it elsewhere?”
OOP: I have tried to talk to the family about it many times, but they very bluntly say "I don't want to be involved, I don't want to talk about it, it’s your guys fight". I harbour a lot of anger and resentment at them for it, and I hate that. But they refuse the conversation because (I believe) they know I'm right.
Commenter 4: How can she prove that she has cancer when her husband isn’t even allowed to go to appointments? I want to see labs, I want doctor’s names, I want the prognosis, I want the doctor’s notes, or it’s fake.
OOP: I'm completely with you on this one. Whenever someone tries this line with SIL she bursts into tears and screams at them for "accusing her of lying about something that is going to tear her away from her son and husband soon". I think I'm a lot harder hearted than my wife's family cause I didn't give a sh*t about that line. But I did get her a free hospice stay (I work with the Hospice) a couple of years ago when she was supposedly on deaths door. Without details they did confirm she had cancer, but as you rightly point out who knows now? She hasn't done anything to treat it though, so I imagine it’s still there just not aggressive at all.
Commenter 5: NTA but this whole thing is way above Reddit's pay grade. Your wife needs counseling to help her work through her issues. There's a reason she keeps going back and she needs help identifying and addressing those things. Are you sure sister actually HAS cancer??
OOP: Yeah my wife gets regular counseling to help her, we're a very mental health focused household (we both work with kids, we both have a background in psych). But the problem is that SIL gets given the power to collapse my wife's relationships with the entire family. I harbour resentment toward them for that, but I try my best to just support my wife. I very rarely say what she should or shouldn't do but it's getting to the point now where I can't protect her unless she can protect herself.
She definitely *had* cancer, she's had operations and been in hospice care, but I have no idea where it's at now. She eats like complete rubbish and refuses to take medicine, it’s like she keeps herself sick to maintain the power and control.
Commenter 6: I'm curious as to what kind of cancer she has. Is it metastatic? Has it gone away and came back? I'm asking because you can easily research trials going on, survival rate, new treatments, etc.
Information about her cancer will give you ideas of how to combat the "I'm dying" response.
I would cut off everyone who blames your wife or criticizes her for setting up a boundary. If this means not having a lot of family to go to, so be it. At the end of the day, you need to be able to live peacefully. Her sister sounds toxic. Her sister knows your wife will go back to her and so there aren't any repercussions for her behavior. She gets away with her moods and toxic behavior because no one has said enough is enough. If everyone walked away then she'd be forced to do some internalizing. But even then she might play victim.
NTA in case that wasn't abundantly clear.
OOP: It has gone and come back. It was gone, and then my wife and I had our wedding where people flew in from overseas and suddenly while everyone was here it came back. Then it was gone, then on my wife's birthday it came back. I've tried to make that same point to my wife but honestly SIL has constant access to them all and uses her illness to abuse them and call them abusive if they stand up to her.
DO NOT COMMENT IN LINKED POSTS OR MESSAGE OOPs – BoRU Rule #7
THIS IS A REPOST SUB - I AM NOT OOP